We respect your privacy.

May I Please Have Your Recipe?

Blog.Pimento Cheese Recipe.png

May I Please Have Your Recipe?

That question always energizes me. And after my friend Beth’s husband made yet another sweeping loop past the appetizer, I understood her request! The delectable in question—

Pimento Cheese*

Three generations (with five individuals actually sharing the same name) mingled, and conversations flowed easily during our Labor Day gathering. No one objected to the noise and interruptions from energetic youngsters. One child needed the dress up clothes; a pair needed a ball and bat. When one toddler impolitely pushed another, no one overreacted. Gentleness flowed with the correction. In this group, we simply relished the joy of shared time and space. For a few precious hours, busy took a backseat to genuine, authentic fellowship, the kind The Bible talks about.

And as we talked, we consumed pimento cheese. While refilling glasses of ice tea… between scuffles… and waiting for the burgers on the grill, we savored the creamy culinary creation, and marveled that each bite tasted better than the one before.

Labor Day is a distant memory, but Thanksgiving is here.

Since pimento cheese transitions well between holidays and households, I often get Beth’s request from others. So just in time for your Thanksgiving gathering, here it is! The ingredients are few, the procedure is important, and the options abound.


Cheddar cheese - Kraft sharp 8 oz. block (not grated)

Blog.cheddar cheese.jpg

Roasted peppers - Mezzetta deli-sliced roasted pepper strips

Blog.red peppersunnamed.jpg

Mayonnaise – Kraft real mayo


Procedure using a food processor:

  • Drain the peppers in a colander, but do not rinse.

  • Using the knife blade, chop the peppers in the food processor and remove to drain again.

  • Switch to the grater blade and grate the block of cheese.

  • Remove the grater blade, replace the knife blade, and add 1/3 cup of mayonnaise, the cheese, and the peppers.

  • Pulse cautiously to a texture blended somewhere between chunky and creamy, depending on your preference.

  • Remove your pimento cheese, stir in fresh ground pepper, savor a sample with a cracker, and place in the refrigerator.

Procedure using a hand mixer:

  • Drain the peppers.

  • Grate the cheese by hand.

  • Cut the pepper strips into shorter lengths, the smaller the better.

  • Place the two ingredients into a mixing bowl, and blend together with hand mixer.

  • Add the mayonnaise and fresh ground pepper and blend to desired texture.

  • Remove, savor a sample with a cracker, and place in the refrigerator.

Note: when you are ready to serve, stir in additional mayonnaise if the mixture seems stiff. Avoid the tendency to add too much, as this will alter the flavors that have blended.

Options for use:

  • as an appetizer served with crackers

    (For Labor Day, I served the pimento cheese in a Bolesławiec pottery bowl at the end of our kitchen island. For the guests’ convenience, party sized plates, individual spreaders, small napkins, and Triscuit crackers were nearby.)

  • on a sandwich with lettuce and tomato

  • as a topping for a burger

  • inside celery sticks

  • as a variation for grilled cheese

The Secret:

Three simple ingredients, but no substitutions—

Standing in the grocery aisle, you will be tempted to substitute these dependable ingredients. Don’t do it. Let me explain. For years I made this simple recipe when we lived in Hungary, the land known for its delicious roasted red peppers. And I had to grate my cheese since the prepackaged grated variety was not available. Then, when I returned to the U.S. and started substituting with the grated package, the taste of my pimento cheese was radically changed. It took a tutorial from my eldest daughter to point out my mistake. She was right!


Pimento cheese is not for everyone’s palate. But if you like it, you will like this recipe.

Living With Eternal Intentionality

Most of all, enjoy the blessing of those around you when you are serving this food. Allow Psalm 103 to guide you and yours to a deeper level of gratitude.

Please let me know what you think, after you have tried the recipe.

*And, as always when I share a recipe, I ask if you would please pray for me when you make it.